Moldova Convicted at ECtHR: The State Is to Pay 67,750 Euros for Moral Damages

Moldova Convicted at ECtHR: The State Is to Pay 67,750 Euros for Moral Damages
by
20 September 2021 | 18:53

The European Court of Human Rights issued a ruling on Tuesday, September 14, in the case of Petrenco and six other people against Moldova, recognizing the violation of several articles of the Convention by Moldova, announces the Promo-LEX Association.

According to the Association, the case concerns the arrest and detention of the applicants on the basis of allegations of mass disturbances, following a demonstration they organized in front of the General Prosecutor’s Office in September 2015. All the applicants were detained for four and a half months in Penitentiary no. 13 and, for approximately the same period of time, were under house arrest. While they were under house arrest, the applicants were forced to wear electronic bracelets, which they had to charge every five hours.

The Court ordered the Moldovan Government to pay the applicants the total amount of 63,750 euros for non-pecuniary damage, for the violations committed, and the sum of 4,000 for costs and expenses of representation and legal assistance before the ECtHR.

”The applicants complained to the ECtHR about the following violations of the Convention: the first applicant had complained about the conditions of detention in Penitentiary no. 13. The applicant’s detention in Penitentiary no. 13 was inhuman and degrading treatment, in violation of Articles 3 and 8 of the Convention.

All applicants complain, under Article 5 § 1 of the Convention, that deprivation of liberty was not based on a reasonable suspicion that they had committed a crime and that their detention was arbitrary and illegal. They also complain, pursuant to Article 5 §§ 3 and 4, that their deprivation of liberty was not based on relevant and sufficient grounds and that the national courts did not give sufficient reasons for their judgments on the application and extension of preventive measures.

All, with the exception of the first applicant, complained under Article 11 of the Convention that the applicants’ right to peaceful assembly had been violated, as a precautionary measure, of prohibitions on going to places where mass protests were taking place. With the exception of the first and fourth applicants, the applicants complain, in accordance with Article 13, that they have not had an effective remedy against the violation of Article 11 of the Convention (concerning the prohibition laid down by the court to participate in public meetings),” say the Promo-LEX representatives.

After examining the videos of the demonstration of 6 September 2015, included in the case file, according to Promo-LEX, the Court found that the allegations of the applicants’ violent behavior were completely incompatible with the footage contained in those videos.

At the same time, the ECtHR found that Judge Svetlana Balmuș of the Court of Appeal stated in her separate opinion that the meeting was peaceful. The Court also noted the finding of the Supreme Court of Justice in its decision of 11 February 2020 with regard to the conviction of the applicants, the lower courts relied exclusively on the presentation of the facts presented by the prosecution and that they did not pay attention to the evidence of the defense.

“This case highlights systemic issues related to the legality and validity of the application and extension of pre-trial detention measures, as well as the restriction of the right to freedom of assembly by applying, as a provisional measure, the ban on going to places with mass protests. The court finds the lack of reasonable suspicion regarding the commission of the crime and the arbitrary assessment of the evidence by the court, by exclusively reproducing the position of the accusation,” said the Promo-LEX Program Director and the lawyer Vadim Vieru.

AUTHOR MAIL eng.zdg@gmail.com

 .

The Romanian interim Minister of Energy, Virgil Popescu: “Romania will send fuel oil to Chișinău as long as it is needed”

The Romanian interim Minister of Energy, Virgil Popescu, states that Romania explores various solutions to help Moldova overcome the crisis in the energy sector. In an interview given to the Digi 24 television…
The Romanian interim Minister of Energy, Virgil Popescu: “Romania will send fuel oil to Chișinău as long as it is needed”

Chairman of the Venice Commission, Gianni Buquicchio, Visits Moldova to Discuss the Amendments to the Law on Prosecutor’s Office

During a working visit to Chișinău, the chairman of the European Commission for Democracy through Law (Venice Commission), Gianni Buquicchio, mentioned that the Venice Commission will come in the next period wi…
Chairman of the Venice Commission, Gianni Buquicchio, Visits Moldova to Discuss the Amendments to the Law on Prosecutor’s Office

PRESS RELEASE: The PACE Monitoring Co-rapporteurs Welcome the Authorities’ Determined Action to Reform the Judicial System and Fight Corruption

Strasbourg, 20.10.2021 – At the end of a fact-finding visit to the Republic of Moldova (12-15 October), the monitoring co-rapporteurs of the Parliamentary Assembly of the Council of Europe (PACE), Inese Lībiņa-…
PRESS RELEASE: The PACE Monitoring Co-rapporteurs Welcome the Authorities’ Determined Action to Reform the Judicial System and Fight Corruption

PRESS RELEASE: EU Highlights the Need for Continued Implementation of the Reform Agenda Strasbourg, 19 October 2021

Today, the European Union has published a report on the Association Implementation of the EU-Republic of Moldova Association Agreement. The report is published ahead of the 6th EU-Moldova Association Council on…
PRESS RELEASE: EU Highlights the Need for Continued Implementation of the Reform Agenda Strasbourg, 19 October 2021

The National Platform of the Eastern Partnership Civil Society Forum: ”We condemn the Russian Federation’s energy blackmail and call on the Moldovan Government and development partners to diversify natural gas supplies”

The member organizations of the National Platform of the Eastern Partnership Civil Society Forum follow with concern the developments regarding the negotiation with Gazprom on the supply of natural gas to Moldo…
The National Platform of the Eastern Partnership Civil Society Forum: ”We condemn the Russian Federation’s energy blackmail and call on the Moldovan Government and development partners to diversify natural gas supplies”

In the Next Two Weeks, the Moldovan Parliament will Receive Delegations from Several Parliamentary Committees from Abroad

In the next two weeks, the Moldovan Parliament will receive delegations from several parliamentary committees from abroad. The officials will have meetings with the President of the Parliament, Igor Grosu, and…
In the Next Two Weeks, the Moldovan Parliament will Receive Delegations from Several Parliamentary Committees from Abroad